
One of the first steps in creating a historical narrative is deciding exactly which moment to portray. We have to ask ourselves “What is the climax of the story? When does the drama reach its peak?” and then come up with the composition that best expresses that moment. On some paintings we have unlimited possibilities as to what angles, colors and elements we can use. However, when you’re depicting a subject that has been well documented, the facts surrounding the subject often limit the amount of creativity you can apply to the scene. Fortunately on this piece, I had one of those “Ah-Ha” moments that we, as artists, all love - when compositions appears out the ether and manifests themselves in the our minds. I could clearly visualize Richthofen in his Albatros is going head-to-head with Cunnell and Woodbridge in the FE. We’re basically along for the ride with Richthofen and the big lumbering FE is looming directly ahead.
Once I had an idea and direction, the next step was to create a series of thumbnail sketches. I don’t spend a lot of time trying to get lines and proportions correct in thumbnail sketches because at this stage I’m working quickly. My aim, of course, is to draw airplanes, what I’m really looking at in this stage is mainly an abstract pattern. In order for a composition to work, the underlying abstract form has to be strong. When you see a painting from across a room, generally what first catches your eye is the underlying abstract pattern. This holds true even with representational art. Our brains take in and process this underlying form on a subconscious level before our eyes begin to interpret the details. If the abstract design is weak then the composition as a whole won’t hold together.
In addition to my abstract forms, I am also trying to tell my story and tell it concisely. This is something that was driven home for me early in my career while taking a workshop from the well-known aviation artist Gil Cohen. Prior to the workshop Gil instructed the participants to work up a series of thumbnail sketches from which we would select one in the workshop to develop into a larger idea.Being young and cocky (and naive!) at the time I thought that I had created the world's best thumbnails sketches and that Gil was going to be amazed by my ideas and creativity. Quite the opposite happened! Looking at one of my drawings, Gil Cohen asked me “What is this? What are you trying to say?” In actuality, my thumbnail ideas were nothing but a disorganized mess. Gil explained to me that a painting should, for the most part, be self-explanatory. Its a well known fact that a picture is worth a thousand words. Regardless of the subject and the viewer’s level of familiarity with it, anyone should be able to view a painting and immediately grasp the basic idea of what is happening in it.
For The Eagle and the Butterfly I tried to picture what it would have been like if I had been along for the ride with Richthofen. I picture everything happening quickly - almost in the blink of an eye. Since we’re riding along with Richthofen in a sense, we see his aircraft in detail. The FE2, on the other hand, is almost an impression - a vision of a hulking form lumbering directly towards us. The sun, being directly above and behind the FE, washes out some of the detail. Bullets are flying all around, leaving phosphorus trails in their wake.
Once I get the initial idea down on paper I’ll often test the positioning of the aircraft using scale models in order to get an idea of the proportions and distances that I’m dealing with. This is a piece I did several years ago involving two aircraft in a head-on pass. The benefit of using the models in a composition such as this where the aircraft are in close proximity to one another is that they play a crucial role in helping to visualize the positions, directions and relative sizes of the aircraft. Taking the models outside, I shot the setup with the aircraft in their correct position just to make sure everything would work.

After I had tested the positioning of the models and knew where I want to go with the painting I then created a more precise pencil sketch which would also serve as a value map for the painting.

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________To
Introduction, Part 1- My Approach
Introduction, Part 2 - The Four Aspects of Realism
Step 1 - The Story Behind the Painting
• Step 2 - Idea and Composition
